How To Get To Fishers Island From NYC? There is no direct connection from New York to Fishers Island. However, you can take the train to New London, take the walk to New London, then take the car. The quickest way to get from New York to Fishers Island is to drive and car ferry which costs ₹3,900 – ₹4,800 and takes 3h 27m. How long is the ferry ride from New London to Fishers Island? about 45 minutes How do you get into Fisher Island? To get to Fisher Island, you take the MacArthur Causeway between Miami and Miami Beach and drive to Terminal Island. You can then drive…